CRDs and Roth Conversions: Abuse of the Rules?

The coronavirus-related distribution (CRD) rules for Roth conversions have a gaping hole.

An “affected person” (as we have defined in previous blogs), is entitled under the CARES Act to withdraw up to $100,000 from their IRA or workplace retirement plan. A CRD avoids the 10% early distribution penalty for those under 59 ½ , can be repaid to a qualified retirement account within three years, and allows the account owner to spread the income (and subsequent taxes due) over a three-year period.

The coronavirus pandemic has decimated the world’s economy. In the United States, unemployment levels rival the Great Depression. Businesses are shuttered. Food banks are strained as desperate families wait patiently for a box of groceries. Hospital staffs are exhausted, and the number of dead increases daily. CRDs are designed to help those most in need by providing access to a source of last-resort, emergency funds. The 3-year repayment option allows profoundly “affected people” to make their account whole once the economy turns, and the 3-year tax spread helps soften the monetary pain of the withdrawal.

The CARES Act does not appear to preclude an affected person from taking a CRD and immediately rolling those dollars into a Roth as a conversion. The taxes can then be spread over the CRD-allowable 3-year period. Individuals who do not need the money from their retirement account due to a coronavirus emergency, but who can otherwise shoehorn themselves into the definition of an “affected person,” could abuse this loophole.

Does a CRD and immediate Roth conversion violate the “spirit” of the law? I certainly think so. Will I look sideways at those who maneuver their way into such a transaction? Absolutely. Will my disapproval make them lose any sleep at night? Probably not.

America’s Tax Solutions®, the #1 Provider of Retirement Distribution Strategies, is the only community-based, one-stop resource specializing in retirement distribution planning and related tax mitigation. Few investors realize that the federal government is actually the primary beneficiary of their retirement accounts and, unless the take specific steps to “disinherit” Uncle Sam, they could lose anywhere from 35% to 80% of their retirement to taxes.
The rules surrounding distributions from retirement accounts are especially complex. Therefore, we will be sending you our exclusive Tax Tips periodically to help you understand the tax code, so you can maximize your clients’ retirement. To ensure compliance requirements imposed by the IRS, we inform you that, unless specifically indicated otherwise, any tax advice contained in this communication was not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for purpose of (i) avoiding tax-related penalties under Internal Revenue Code, or (ii) promoting, marketing, or recommending to another party any tax-related matter addressed herein.
This is not intended as a solicitation or advertisement for legal services. The information contained herein is not intended as legal advice.